The Open Door | Articles

Home Insurance Tips for First-Time Buyers | Openly

Written by Alyssa Little | Jun 19, 2025 10:06:23 PM

Congratulations on taking the exciting leap into homeownership! 

You’re probably overwhelmed by the flurry of paperwork, mortgage applications, and packing boxes, and securing the right home insurance might feel like just another item on a long checklist. However, as a first-time buyer, understanding your house insurance options and making informed decisions is important for protecting your home—and wallet. 

At a glance: 

  • Home insurance is an essential financial protection for first-time buyers, often required by lenders.
  • Determining the right coverage involves assessing replacement costs, inventorying belongings, and understanding factors that influence premiums.
  • Shopping for policies wisely includes working with independent agents, comparing coverage and service, and understanding deductibles and exclusions.

Why insurance is a key step in homeownership

Becoming a homeowner is a dream come true for most. It's a chance to build equity, create lasting memories, and establish roots in a community. However, it also comes with significant financial responsibility. 

Home insurance is a cornerstone of this responsibility; a financial safety net against unforeseen events that could otherwise lead to devastating losses.

Do you have to buy home insurance?

For most first-time buyer situations involving a mortgage, the answer to “do I have to have home insurance?” is yes. Lenders typically require you to have homeowners insurance in place before they will finalize your loan. This protects their investment in your property.

Even if you're a cash buyer, forgoing insurance is a significant financial risk, and one best avoided. Could you afford to rebuild your house from the ground up after a fire or natural disaster? 

How insurance protects more than just your lender

While your mortgage lender has a vested interest in the structural integrity of your home, your homeowners insurance policy is designed to protect you first and foremost. It helps safeguard your investment, providing financial assistance to repair or rebuild your house if it's damaged by a covered peril. 

Beyond the structure itself, insurance can also help cover the costs of replacing damaged personal belongings and even provide liability protection if someone is injured on your property. This prevents you from facing potentially crippling out-of-pocket expenses.

Common misconceptions

As a first-time buyer, you might encounter some confusion surrounding different types of insurance. It's essential to clarify the distinction between private mortgage insurance (PMI) and homeowners insurance. 

PMI protects the lender if you default on your mortgage. Homeowners insurance, on the other hand, protects your home and belongings against covered risks. They are entirely separate policies serving different purposes.

What a standard homeowners insurance policy covers

Understanding what homeowners insurance covers is important for all homeowners, but especially first-time buyers who likely are unfamiliar with the product.

Dwelling coverage

Dwelling coverage pays to repair or rebuild the physical structure of your home, including the walls, roof, foundation, and any attached structures like a garage or deck, if they are damaged by a covered peril. Common covered perils include fire, windstorms, hail, lightning, and certain types of water damage. The amount of dwelling coverage you need should be based on the cost to rebuild your house at current construction prices, not its current market value.

It is important to note that unattached structures are covered under their own classification in standard home insurance policies, known as other structures coverage, with their own limits and exclusions. 

Personal property

Personal property coverage helps you replace clothing, furniture, electronics, kitchenware, and other household items. While loss or damage to personal property caused by covered perils is included in standard home insurance policies, it's important to understand whether you are covered under an actual cash value (ACV) or replacement cost value (RCV)

Liability protection

Life happens, and sometimes accidents occur on your property. Liability coverage helps pay for legal or medical bills if someone is injured on your premises and you are found legally responsible. It can also cover damages you or members of your household cause to someone else's property, even if it happens away from your home. 

Loss of use

If a covered event makes your home uninhabitable, loss of use coverage can provide reimbursement for additional living expenses you incur while your house is being repaired or rebuilt. This can include costs for temporary housing, meals, and other necessary expenses above your normal living costs.

What isn’t typically covered by home insurance


While homeowners insurance offers broad protection, it's important for first-time buyers to understand its limitations. Standard homeowners insurance policies typically do not cover certain events, including the following:

Flooding, earthquakes, and other natural disasters

Standard home insurance policies generally exclude damage caused by floods and earthquakes. If your property is located in an area prone to these events, you will likely need to purchase separate flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurance provider, and earthquake insurance through a specialized policy or rider. Other natural disasters like landslides or sinkholes may also require specific coverage depending on your location.

Maintenance issues vs. sudden damage

Home insurance is designed to cover sudden and accidental damage, not issues arising from lack of maintenance or normal wear and tear. For example, a burst pipe causing water damage would likely be covered, but a leaky faucet that has been dripping for months and caused mold growth may not.

When you might need extra coverage or riders

Standard home insurance policies have limits on the amount they will pay for certain types of personal property, such as jewelry, artwork, collectibles, and firearms. If you own valuable items that exceed these limits, you may need to purchase additional coverage or an endorsement (also called a rider).

How much coverage do you actually need for your home?

Determining the right amount of home insurance coverage can feel overwhelming for first-time buyers. Here are some key considerations:

Replacement cost vs. market value

As mentioned earlier, your dwelling coverage should be based on the replacement cost of your home, or the amount it would take to rebuild it at today’s prices for labor and materials. This is often different from the market value.

Inventory your belongings

Take the time to create a basic home inventory of your personal belongings, including descriptions, estimated values, serial numbers, and photos. This will not only help you determine if your personal property coverage limits are sufficient but will also be invaluable if you ever need to file a claim. 

Factors that affect premiums

The cost of your home insurance premium is influenced by a number of factors. Your location plays a significant role, as areas with higher crime rates or a greater risk of natural disasters typically have higher premiums. The materials your home is constructed with, the age of your house, and even your claims history can also affect your insurance cost.

Tips for shopping homeowners insurance policies

Finding the right home insurance policy requires some research and comparison. 

Why work with an independent insurance agent 

An independent insurance agent works with multiple insurance companies, meaning they can provide you with quotes from various providers. Independent insurance agents can help you understand the nuances of different policies, explain complex terms, and ensure you get personalized home insurance coverage that meets your specific needs as a new homeowner. 

What to look for in a quote

Carefully review the coverage levels, deductibles, and exclusions. Ensure the dwelling coverage is adequate, the personal property limits meet your needs, and the liability protection offers sufficient safeguards. Pay attention to the service reputation and claims experience of the insurance companies you are considering.

Deductibles, sub-limits, and exclusions

A higher deductible typically results in a lower premium, but make sure you are comfortable paying that amount if you need to file a claim. Be aware of any sub-limits within your policy, which are limits on specific types of property or losses, and understand the exclusions.

Smart ways to save on home insurance

As a first-time buyer, you're likely looking for ways to manage your new expenses. Here are some strategies to consider that may lower your home insurance premiums:

  • Bundling home and auto insurance—Many insurance companies offer discounts when you bundle your auto and home insurance policies with the same provider.

  • Install safety features—Smoke detectors, carbon monoxide detectors, burglar alarms, and sprinkler systems may qualify you for insurance discounts.

  • Adjust your deductible—Ensure you have a sufficient savings cushion to comfortably pay that deductible if you need to file a claim. It's a balancing act between lower monthly cost and potential out-of-pocket expenses.

Avoid these common homeowners insurance mistakes

First-time buyers can sometimes make mistakes when it comes to home insurance. 

Underestimating rebuild costs

Relying on the market value or even your mortgage amount can leave you underinsured. Get a realistic estimate of replacement cost from your local independent insurance agent or an independent appraisal to ensure you have adequate dwelling coverage.

Forgetting to update coverage as life changes

Your insurance needs can change over time. If you make significant renovations to your home, purchase valuable new items, or experience other life changes, remember to review your policy and update your coverage accordingly to avoid being underinsured.

Why first-time buyers choose Openly for home insurance

At Openly, we understand that navigating home insurance as a first-time buyer can be daunting. That's why Openly offers clear home insurance protection with customizable options and no hidden surprises.

While our process is tech-driven, we believe in the power of personalized advice. Openly policies are delivered through trusted local independent agents who understand your unique needs and can help you tailor your coverage to your specific situation.

Securing the right home insurance is a critical step in your homeownership journey.  By educating yourself on the nuances of home insurance coverage and avoiding common mistakes, you can protect your investment and enjoy the security that comes with owning your own home. 

Welcome to the world of homeownership!

 

We provide this information to help you understand insurance. Any coverage is subject to the terms of your policy. Please refer to your policy and declarations page for complete terms, conditions, exclusions and coverage details. Openly may provide links that lead to an external website that may promote goods and services that Openly does not endorse. We are not responsible for the content, claims, or representations made on the linked website. Please review their terms and policies before engaging with any offerings.